When Jeff and Rebecca Payne danced their first dance on Route 35 in Dayton, Ohio, it wasn’t anything near as romantic as the first place their eyes met as they were driving in that exact spot.

The couple were on their way to their wedding reception when a wreck closed down the interstate. The couple were disappointed at first but decided to “turn lemons into lemonade” by turning up the car radio and dancing their first dance to Alison Krauss’ “When You Say Nothing At All.” Those around them who realized what was going on joined in the celebration.